{
 "instrument": "The First Rung Map",
 "subtitle": "From the Universal HBCU Workforce Alignment Model",
 "version": "1.0 build preview",
 "vintage": "July 2026",
 "families": [
  {
   "id": "business",
   "cip": "52",
   "label": "Business, Management, Marketing, and Related Support Services"
  },
  {
   "id": "psychology",
   "cip": "42",
   "label": "Psychology"
  },
  {
   "id": "biology",
   "cip": "26",
   "label": "Biological and Biomedical Sciences"
  },
  {
   "id": "social_work",
   "cip": "44",
   "label": "Public Administration and Social Service Professions"
  },
  {
   "id": "criminal_justice",
   "cip": "43",
   "label": "Homeland Security, Law Enforcement, Firefighting and Related Protective Services"
  },
  {
   "id": "education",
   "cip": "13",
   "label": "Education"
  },
  {
   "id": "communications",
   "cip": "09",
   "label": "Communication, Journalism, and Related Programs"
  },
  {
   "id": "computer_science",
   "cip": "11",
   "label": "Computer and Information Sciences and Support Services"
  },
  {
   "id": "health_professions",
   "cip": "51",
   "label": "Health Professions and Related Programs"
  },
  {
   "id": "engineering",
   "cip": "14",
   "label": "Engineering"
  },
  {
   "id": "sociology",
   "cip": "45",
   "label": "Social Sciences"
  },
  {
   "id": "english",
   "cip": "23",
   "label": "English Language and Literature/Letters"
  },
  {
   "id": "math",
   "cip": "27",
   "label": "Mathematics and Statistics"
  },
  {
   "id": "visual_performing_arts",
   "cip": "50",
   "label": "Visual and Performing Arts"
  },
  {
   "id": "history",
   "cip": "54",
   "label": "History"
  },
  {
   "id": "physical_sciences",
   "cip": "40",
   "label": "Physical Sciences"
  }
 ],
 "benchmarks": {
  "active": "State floor shown: published CY2024 federal threshold (labor-force basis), serving as proxy until the Department publishes AHEAD-specific values",
  "national": 31269,
  "values": {
   "PA": 31727,
   "MS": 27362,
   "LA": 28996,
   "AL": 27836,
   "GA": 29609,
   "NC": 29344,
   "SC": 30156,
   "TX": 31171,
   "VA": 33043,
   "TN": 29609,
   "MD": 33397,
   "FL": 29609,
   "OH": 30793,
   "DE": 31316,
   "DC": 32592,
   "MO": 30156,
   "KY": 28996,
   "AR": 28502,
   "OK": 29810,
   "WV": 28996
  },
  "universe_note": "The AHEAD framework (91 FR 40136) uses a working-only universe (worked and not enrolled during the measured year) and measures completer earnings four years after completion. Its floor will generally sit somewhat higher than the values below. Never present these values as the AHEAD determination."
 },
 "ai_layer": {
  "25-9045": {
   "soc": "25-9045",
   "label": "Teaching Assistants, Except Postsecondary",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": "not_covered",
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.169,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "21-1018": {
   "soc": "21-1018",
   "label": "Substance Abuse, Behavioral Disorder, and Mental Health Counselors",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": "not_covered",
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.18,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "11-9151": {
   "soc": "11-9151",
   "label": "Social and Community Service Managers",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.446,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.25,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "11-9151.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.156,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "21-1021": {
   "soc": "21-1021",
   "label": "Child, Family, and School Social Workers",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.3,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.171,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "21-1021.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.334,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "21-1022": {
   "soc": "21-1022",
   "label": "Healthcare Social Workers",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.422,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.188,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "21-1022.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.189,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "21-1012": {
   "soc": "21-1012",
   "label": "Educational, Guidance, and Career Counselors and Advisors",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.325,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.246,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "21-1012.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.325,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "39-9041": {
   "soc": "39-9041",
   "label": "Residential Advisors",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.28,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.18,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "39-9041.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.144,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "29-2053": {
   "soc": "29-2053",
   "label": "Psychiatric Technicians",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.34,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.16,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "29-2053.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.062,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "13-1071": {
   "soc": "13-1071",
   "label": "Human Resources Specialists",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.589,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.378,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "13-1071.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.201,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "13-1151": {
   "soc": "13-1151",
   "label": "Training and Development Specialists",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.592,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.421,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "13-1151.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.242,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "21-1013": {
   "soc": "21-1013",
   "label": "Marriage and Family Therapists",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.278,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.185,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "21-1013.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.231,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "29-1141": {
   "soc": "29-1141",
   "label": "Registered Nurses",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.381,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.19,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "29-1141.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.122,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "29-2011": {
   "soc": "29-2011",
   "label": "Clinical Laboratory Technologists and Technicians",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk; SOC 2018 splits this series, confirm at join",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.232,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.143,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "29-2011.00"
   },
   "applicability": "not_covered",
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "31-9092": {
   "soc": "31-9092",
   "label": "Medical Assistants",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.141,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.051,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "31-9092.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.069,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "25-1099": {
   "soc": "25-1099",
   "label": "Postsecondary Teachers, All Other",
   "acs_occ_note": "ACS pools postsecondary teachers; confirm at join",
   "exposure": "not_covered",
   "applicability": "not_covered",
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "25-2021": {
   "soc": "25-2021",
   "label": "Elementary School Teachers, Except Special Education",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.311,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.135,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "25-2021.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.189,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "25-2031": {
   "soc": "25-2031",
   "label": "Secondary School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.341,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.159,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "25-2031.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.176,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "33-3051": {
   "soc": "33-3051",
   "label": "Police and Sheriff's Patrol Officers",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.233,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.138,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "33-3051.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.143,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "33-3012": {
   "soc": "33-3012",
   "label": "Correctional Officers and Jailers",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.239,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.114,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "33-3012.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.108,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "21-1092": {
   "soc": "21-1092",
   "label": "Probation Officers and Correctional Treatment Specialists",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.447,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.289,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "21-1092.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.288,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "23-2011": {
   "soc": "23-2011",
   "label": "Paralegals and Legal Assistants",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.45,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.05,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "23-2011.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.057,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "13-2011": {
   "soc": "13-2011",
   "label": "Accountants and Auditors",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.52,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.2,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "13-2011.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.195,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "13-1161": {
   "soc": "13-1161",
   "label": "Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.577,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.231,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "13-1161.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.35,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "43-4051": {
   "soc": "43-4051",
   "label": "Customer Service Representatives",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.705,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.545,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "43-4051.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.408,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation",
   "evidence_note": "Stanford Canaries places customer service among high-exposure automating categories with early-career decline; strongest candidate for the first-rung flag pending the other two conditions"
  },
  "43-6014": {
   "soc": "43-6014",
   "label": "Secretaries and Administrative Assistants, Except Legal, Medical, and Executive",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.567,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.365,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "43-6014.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.256,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "43-3021": {
   "soc": "43-3021",
   "label": "Billing and Posting Clerks",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.417,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.19,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "43-3021.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.223,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "13-1111": {
   "soc": "13-1111",
   "label": "Management Analysts",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.5,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.19,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "13-1111.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.353,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "19-4061": {
   "soc": "19-4061",
   "label": "Social Science Research Assistants",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.621,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.394,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "19-4061.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.204,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  },
  "21-1094": {
   "soc": "21-1094",
   "label": "Community Health Workers",
   "acs_occ_note": "pending crosswalk",
   "exposure": {
    "headline": 0.347,
    "measure": "human_rating_beta (E1 + 0.5*E2)",
    "alpha_lower_bound": 0.278,
    "source": "Eloundou et al., GPTs are GPTs, Science 2024, occ_level.csv (MIT)",
    "onet_soc_matched": "21-1094.00"
   },
   "applicability": {
    "score": 0.297,
    "source": "Tomlinson et al., Working with AI, Microsoft Research 2025, ai_applicability_scores.csv (CC BY 4.0)"
   },
   "auto_aug": {
    "status": "pending_source",
    "note": "Anthropic Economic Index occupation file pending re-upload after encoding issue; column ships as pending, never imputed"
   },
   "first_rung_flag": "pending_evaluation"
  }
 },
 "fans": {
  "psychology": {
   "status": "DEMONSTRATION STRUCTURE \u2014 occupation shares and medians populate from the ACS 2020-2024 5-year PUMS build pipeline before launch; do not cite",
   "destinations": [
    {
     "soc": "21-1021",
     "label": "Child, Family, and School Social Workers"
    },
    {
     "soc": "21-1018",
     "label": "Substance Abuse, Behavioral Disorder, and Mental Health Counselors"
    },
    {
     "soc": "11-9151",
     "label": "Social and Community Service Managers"
    },
    {
     "soc": "13-1071",
     "label": "Human Resources Specialists"
    },
    {
     "soc": "43-4051",
     "label": "Customer Service Representatives"
    },
    {
     "soc": "25-9045",
     "label": "Teaching Assistants, Except Postsecondary"
    }
   ]
  },
  "business": {
   "status": "DEMONSTRATION STRUCTURE \u2014 occupation shares and medians populate from the ACS 2020-2024 5-year PUMS build pipeline before launch; do not cite",
   "destinations": [
    {
     "soc": "13-2011",
     "label": "Accountants and Auditors"
    },
    {
     "soc": "13-1071",
     "label": "Human Resources Specialists"
    },
    {
     "soc": "43-4051",
     "label": "Customer Service Representatives"
    },
    {
     "soc": "13-1111",
     "label": "Management Analysts"
    },
    {
     "soc": "13-1161",
     "label": "Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists"
    },
    {
     "soc": "43-6014",
     "label": "Secretaries and Administrative Assistants"
    }
   ]
  }
 },
 "headline_exposure_note": "human_rating_beta per verified GPTs-are-GPTs README (alpha=E1, beta=E1+0.5*E2, gamma=E1+E2); Science 2024 DOI 10.1126/science.adj0998",
 "citation": "Mukherjee, S. (2026). The First Rung Map, from the Universal HBCU Workforce Alignment Model [data instrument], Version 1.0. Mukherjee & Associates LLC. suemukherjee.com/first-rung-map."
}